Cook County Probate Attorneys Reda Ciprian Magnone Chicago

What's best for the client, not what's best for the attorney.


Personal Property in Illinois Probate

Reading appellate court opinions is a hobby of mine.  Not only can you stay abreast of developments in the law, but you often get insights into human nature—occasionally uplifting, but usually, perplexing.

I just read a case, handed down by the Illinois Appellate Court this month, that fell into the latter category—perplexing.  Jennifer Koerner and her boyfriend, Kent Nielsen, like many young couples today, decided to take their romance to the next level by moving in together.    In November, 2010, Koerner purchased a dog, Stig, from an animal shelter for $95.00.  On Christmas Day, 2010, Koerner wrote a poem to Nielsen and informed him in the poem that she was making Stig a Christmas gift to Nielsen.  Unfortunately for these young lovers, the embers of love cooled and in February, 2012, Nielsen and Stig moved out.  During February and March 2012, emails were exchanged between Nielsen and Koerner concerning the logistics of the move out.  Koerner wrote to Nielsen on more than one occasion that she and her dog, Jessie, missed Stig (I guess she no longer missed Nielsen) and urged Nielsen to “bring Stig home”.  Nielsen repeatedly replied that Stig belonged to him.

In April, 2012, Koerner filed a lawsuit against Nielsen alleging that he was withholding from her personal property (Stig) that rightfully belonged to her.  At trial, the court heard testimony from both sides as to the circumstances surrounding Stig’s purchase and the Christmas poem.  At the conclusion of the trial, the court ruled that the burden of proving that Nielsen was wrongfully withholding personal property belonging to Koerner was with Koerner and she had not met her burden of proof.  The court ruled that Nielsen was the true owner of Stig.  Koerner appealed the trial court’s ruling, claiming the court had ignored evidence that Stig’s license registration was still in Koerner’s name, as was the veterinary insurance policy for Stig. Read More


Happy St. Joseph’s Day!

I have to honor my Italian heritage and wish happy St. Joseph’s Day to everyone.   I have always taken great pride in being Italian.  I love the food, the country, the attitude of the people, their creativity throughout history, and on and on.  But one thing I don’t admire about Italians is there ability to be petty and hold grudges.  The word “vendetta” is an Italian word meaning revenge.   The fact that this Italian word has now been assimilated into the English language is no coincidence.

Now don’t get me wrong, every nationality has a segment of the population who are conflict-loving, irrational folks.  But in my 37 years as an attorney, some of the most hard fought family fights occurred in Italian families.  Thirty years ago I witnessed cousins almost come to blows over a used sausage-making machine that each felt had been promised to them by their zia (aunt).  I have seen two brothers each spend over $10,000 in legal fees fighting over household furniture and furnishings that could not have been worth more than $5,000 in total. Read More